gay blog: hate crime, murder, brian brothers, gay news, indiana

Man Goes Unpunished After Killing Drunk, Gay Man At Party

gay blog: hate crime, murder, brian brothers, gay news, indiana
Paul Michalik, killed.

Let me get this straight correct:

  • Paul Michalik and his partner, Jerry Lee Chambers, went to a house party at Brian Brothers’ house.
  • Michalik got buttfaced drunk (Almost three times the legal limit) and pushed Brothers.
  • Brothers beat Michalik to death, carried him out on the front lawn, and left him outside to die with Chambers – and refused to call for medical help.
  • Brothers has been cleared of criminal charges, citing self defense.

Say what now? Wane.com reports:

FORT WAYNE, Ind. (WANE) – The Allen County Prosecutor’s Office has decided not to file charges against Brian Brothers in connection with the May death of Paul Michalik.

Brian Brothers not charged in Michalik death: wane.com

Michalik was found dead on Monte Carlo Drive in Huntertown after a fight with Brothers and was determined to have died as a result of blunt force trauma to the head.

The prosecutor’s office decided not to file charges because they believe Brothers acted in self defense.

Chambers told police they were beaten because they were gay. He said Brothers had punched and kicked Michalik in the face, head and body multiple times as he tried to get Michalik out of his home.

Wednesday, NewsChannel 15 spoke with Chambers over the phone. He said he is disappointed with the prosecutor’s decision. All he wants is to tell his side.

“To tell the truth so help me God is all I want in a just court system,” said Chambers.

Is there something we’re missing here? We’ve read the news release three times trying to understand how beating someone to death, dragging them out of your home, and then refusing to call for medical help falls under the umbrella of “self defense,” whether you were pushed first or not.

I am pushed all of the time. In fact, on my way into a noodle house today for a steaming bowl of pho, my (ex?)friend Dusty from Scenic Boys accidentally pushed me and we knocked over an entire table full of forks. Smash! Clang! Every single patron looking at us with contempt. But did I turn around and beat Dusty to death and drag his corpse out onto the sidewalk before ordering my Pho Ga? Of course not.

So why exactly is Brothers off the hook here? Especially considering the heightened scrutiny the case should be examined under since Chambers, now a widower, has told officers that Brothers killed Michalik because of his sexuality. This case should be investigated as a hate crime, not outright dismissed.

So what gives, Indiana?

Via Wane.com

  • are these murders and other crimes related to this follow each other, like it was planned by certain individuals? i think Google would know the answer to that. Investigation anyone?

  • Toni-Lee Lorenzi

    Where is the petition! Who is starting one? Get this dick head the death sentence!

  • Gus Anderson

    Has a mound of flowers and candles and animal plushies been built in Brother’s yard yet?
    Of course not….we got to go get our votes in on American Idol.
    Maybe a mob of angry Gays; carrying pitchforks and flaming torches, should march to Brother’s home…and swing past police headquarters and the courthouse on their way.

  • I don’t think his crime was hate-motivated but it was still a crime and he needs to be prosecuted. 

  • It’s Indiana. I’ve lived here for pretty much all of my 21 year old life and I can tell you very honestly that discrimination is pretty rampant. For example, recently my former high school expelled a friend of mine who recently came out on the grounds of his sexuality. Most politicians I know in the state, both Democrat and Republican, regularly cite scripture as a means to show their “morality” while dealing with the law; they feel no shame in mixing church and state. Honestly, it’s a lot better than it was when I was I kid, but it’s still got a long way to go. If you really want to change anything in this State, it’s going to require embarrassing the government on a national or international scale. Because this change is sadly not going to come from within.

  • It’s Indiana. I’ve lived here for pretty much all of my 21 year old life and I can tell you very honestly that discrimination is pretty rampant. For example, recently my former high school expelled a friend of mine who recently came out on the grounds of his sexuality. Most politicians I know in the state, both Democrat and Republican, regularly cite scripture as a means to show their “morality” while dealing with the law; they feel no shame in mixing church and state. Honestly, it’s a lot better than it was when I was I kid, but it’s still got a long way to go. If you really want to change anything in this State, it’s going to require embarrassing the government on a national or international scale. Because this change is sadly not going to come from within.